March 01, 2005

TV: American Idol -- women's semifinals, week 2

After the second round of women's performances, the extremes are clear for me. Nadia and Jessica are the best of the lot (though what the hell was Nadia thinking when she chose to do that insipid McCartney song?); Janay and Mikalah (god, that awful nasal voice!) are the worst, and clearly the ones who deserve to go home this week.

In the middle, Vonzell, Carrie, and Aloha seem to have potential, but haven't been consistent; Amanda, Celena, and Lindsey are mediocrities.

No comments: