MOVIES: You Had to Be There (2025, Nick Davis)
The musical Godspell opened off-Broadway in 1971, and was such a hit that new companies began to appear around the world within a few months. This documentary focuses on the 1972 Toronto production, which Lin-Manuel Miranda describes as the "'27 Yankees of comedy." That cast included Victor Garber, Andrea Martin, Eugene Levy, Gilda Radner, Martin Short, and Dave Thomas; Paul Shaffer was the musical director. And those are just the names that are well known in the United States; both Jayne Eastwood and Rudy Webb went on to significant careers in Canada.
The challenge for Nick Davis in making this film is that there is no video footage of the production, and the only audio recording was made by Short, who (without permission) clipped a couple of microphones to the set one night and plugged them into his portable cassette recorder. So we get a lot of talking head interviews from the entire company (except for Radner, who died in 1989), and some low-budget animated re-creations of key moments in the history of the production.
And in large part because this company was made up of such remarkable performers, those interviews are more than enough to tell the story in entertaining fashion. There are terrific memories of Radner's audition, which the rest of the group thought was a disaster; Martin's last-minute addition to the cast; the adjustments made when Garber left the company to make the film version of Godspell.
Not all of the memories are happy. One of the lesser-known members of the cast, Avril Chown, explains why she left show business a few years after Godspell, having dealt with sexual harrassment in her first venture into American television.
"You had to be there" moments can be frustrating for those of us who weren't. But when the members of this cast meet for a reunion, gathering around the piano to sing through the songs one more time, Davis almost manages to make us feel, just a little, as if we had been.